When i was jamming out to metal music these ending for RDR just popped up in my head the first one was johns alt ending when he comes out of the barn but instead of getting blasted away ross just shoots him in the side to talk some bullshit to him and while john is on one knee he drops his gun and right before ross gives the order to fire every one of johns friends come save him like marshal leigh and his deputies,bonnie and drew,reyes and his rebels,jack and abigal,seth and dickens with the gatling gun wagon,and the legendary landon ricketts and when the rest of the army is getting killed ross looks at john and john is looking at ross a draw goes on between them and john must get a headshot and when ross gets shot in the head seth shoots him in half with the gatling gun while he falls,then when it is all over john gets up and his friends greet him and asks how they knew the army was coming and marshal leigh said a man with a top hat with a wierd mustache came and told them all what was gonna happen at the marston's home when johns remembers him h e looks over at the house and see's uncle's body and says he needs to bury him after a month later the marshal comes and tells him that he is dead to the bereau so they will no longer track him and his family down and john thanks him after a week john goes to uncle's grave and looks at it with a small tear coming down his face when he wipes it off and turns around the shadow of the man with the top hat and the camera doesnt show him and john says "i know you" then the credits roll and right before the cradits end a picture of a happy john and a pregnant abigal along with jack with the top of the picture saying "my family,my redemption"
and the other ending will come some other time but this ending seems to over the top but i like it better
let me know if you like it. :)