Thread:Wagwan piffting23/@comment-38834301-20191214035829

Hey there Wagwan. In Red Dead Redemption 1, John mentions that Bill left him to die. There are two occasions of this, once during the mission "Spare the Rod, Spoil the Bandit" (You need to fail the mission to get this specific line of dialogue):

John: Barring in mind, he left me (Bill) to die twice now.

The second is during "An Appointed Time":

John:' 'You shouldn't have left me to die, Bill''.

Bill: Well, no one wanted you around, John.

It's very clear that John is referring to Bill leaving him to die at the robbery. Red Dead Redemption 2 contradicts this by showing that Bill did not, in fact, leave John to die. The ones who left John to die were Dutch, Javier, Micah, and Joe.

I added trivia to the pages for "An Appointed Time" and "Our Best Selves" mentioning this fact. However, on the former page, I somewhat got into a minor edit war (I apologize for that) with another user who claims that the fact that Bill was on Dutch's side, Bill inherently left John to die, something I disagree with. He claims that the Pinkerton attack on Beaver Hollow is what John was referring to, which I think is unlikely.

What do you think? 