Thread:MinmoTheCat/@comment-6554265-20181127175737/@comment-6554265-20181127180714

There's this thing called "putting two and two together". Hosea is talking about his faith in Dutch's virtues and how it shattered during "Blackwater", which is slang for the Blackwater ferry heist, which has been constantly referenced in both games as the time Dutch snapped and killed an innocent. So obviously, Dutch killing Heidi was the final straw for Hosea. Yes, he immediately contradicts himself by saying it was dead long before that, but he mentioned Blackwater for a REASON. He's saying he was in denial for the longest time, but Dutch killing Heidi forced him to accept to truth.