User blog comment:Rdrbandito55/bandito and myths 2: werewolf/@comment-68.153.102.52-20111001221401

I've been hunting that thing since I've learned about it, which wasn't too long ago. I've drawn some conclusions: 1. it's Lobo the Wolf or so I thought due to the facts that he's a rare animal, slightly larger then a normal wolf and the obvious fact that he is black with yellow eyes, but the pictures that I have seen of the werewolf show a much larger creature. Plus I easily baited and killed Lobo with bait which I haven't heard or seen any evidence of this happening with the werewolf.

2. I looked up at the sky before midnight and saw the moon wasn't a full moon, but I rode out towards the werewolf location anyway to hunt wolfs and bears. I climbed up Nekoti Rock and looked at the moon and it was a full moon. The next day in the game the same thing happened, so either it's just me and my game is glitching or Werewolf hunting hours are every night from 12:00-6:00.

3. It may be easier to find/encouter it in Undead due to the fact that mythical creatures and undead creature are more present in the game, but this is more of a logical guess then evidence.

4. Reports have also said it can be spotted in Multiplayer, although this has been said by other people and it may be a rumor due to lack of evidence, but it is worth investigating.

5. Rockstar has done mysteries like this in there previous games like GTA San Andreas and it is possible that they did it again in RDR.

Well that's all the best supporting evidence I have right now, but I'll see if I can find more. If you ever want to go hunting for the beast in multiplayer then send a message to Invader Zak1. Until then happy hunting.