Thread:Raziel Reaper/@comment-38834301-20190908010643/@comment-2008429-20190908163924

The quote "I had a daughter, but she died." Comes from a conversation between John and Bonnie very early in the game. It sounds like he's getting these conversations confused. I just watched a video of the full mission "The Sport of Kings, and Liars" Not once does John mention his daughter to Dickens. I've personally beaten Red Dead Redemption four times now. As far as i'm aware. John only mentions his daughter to Bonnie and Luisa. Only twice in the entire game.

It's possible that RDR2 could contain vague dialogue related to John's daughter. But I think some proof is needed. Because I've beaten the entire story of RDR2 twice with both high and low honor and I don't remember a single reference or allusion to John's daughter anywhere, nor has anyone else found such a thing, to my knowledge.