Thread:Rvb forever/@comment-38834301-20190517211150/@comment-38834301-20190909204842

Thanks for replying to my message, even if it's four months overdue.

The body count was never specified in either game. The newspapers from the first game never mention the body count of the massacre. The only place I could think of where the body count could potentially be mentioned is NPC dialogue.

Now about the Game Of The Year Guide. Recently, I have read The Brady's Game Guide and it gives off the same information as the GOTY guide, such as Bill being a soldier and John being saved from a hanging. It even gives off the same exact bios for the characters.

However, there's an oddity. According to what you said, the GOTY Guide states that Dutch is 56 in 1911. From what I read in the TBG Guide, Dutch is 45 in 1911. Similary, the GOTY Guide supposely states that Bill is 45 in 1911, while the TBG Guide states that Bill is 29 in 1911.

Now, Red Dead Redemption 2 obviously doesn't take TBG Guide ages as canon. But what interests me is that TBG Guide released in 2010, while the GOTY Guide released in 2011, which was around the time Red Dead Redemption 2 was being written. This might mean there are minor changes between these two guide books.

Do you know anybody on the wiki who have the GOTY Guide Book? I would love to compare the differences between the GOTY Guide vs TBG Guide.