Who Are You to Judge?

 is a mission in Red Dead Redemption.

Story
A man named Jeb in Rathskeller Fork asked you to find his lost love, who was kidnapped by gangsters in Tumbleweed. It turns out that Jeb's "love" was in fact a horse, who you rescued and returned to Jeb.

Walkthrough
Start mission by talking to Jeb in Rathskeller Fork.

Head over to the purple "?" blip in Tumbleweed. You will find Jeb"s horse here.

Go back to Jeb with his horse.