User blog comment:Severed3456/New Ending/@comment-4015736-20110616103953

the game is called red dead redemption for a reason the word redemption is the main message of the story john sacrifices his own life so his wife and son can have a great life but jack chose to avenge his father which was a bad thing cause he is now a outlaw which his father didn't want him to be so in some words johns death for redemption was fulfilled but to make his family have a good life his death was for nothing only to let jack mess it up. revenge just leads to more bloodshed