User blog comment:DoctorNick/Edgar Ross, Douche or Good Guy?/@comment-26053909-20120812003439

Honestly I think he's a truly sick man for killing John Marston and when I dueled him I had the Mauser Pistol and I shot that Piece Of Shit in the face 15 times since he killed John. And to be completely honest Edgar and his cowardly assistant Archer Fordham should have killed Dutch's gang them selves instead of lounging around in black water telling John Marston to kill his own friends and then after all of Marston's hard work to find his old gang mates and then Edgar Ross decides to be a dick butt and kill Marston and Uncle and then Three Years Later Jack Kills Edgar for revenge