User blog comment:DoctorNick/Edgar Ross, Douche or Good Guy?/@comment-24901571-20120404090659/@comment-93.161.94.254-20130423234217

Hadron you´re absolutely right. Edgar just did his job. Edgars odre was to kill all of Dutchs gang which, was what he did. John is a criminal. You can not just kill a lot of people and rob a lot of banks and then just say "Fuck this, now i wanna be a good guy " and expect that nothing would happen. plus John was not quite good. I think through the game we all kills a lot of innocent people and rob a few banks so John will always be criminal. The game even says it. It is the game's motto "Outlaw to the end" and Jack you can not compare Edgar with the Nazis. Because the Nazis killed millions of innocent people and Edgar killed one not so innocent man. So all in all, Edgar is the good guy. the only reason you say Edgar is a douche is just because the game is about John and it gets you to understand him. If this was reality, we would all think Edgar was a hero, for example think of those who killed Osama Bin Laden, we hail them and are happy for what they did? but those who knew Osama is probably not as happy and think that those who did it were some douches. You get my point?