User blog comment:ManUtd111/Punch Fights in Red Dead Redemption/@comment-899250-20100609124125

I agree, it is a bit silly that you can never totally win a fist fight, they always come back for more. I've got this trophy, and I found that in most saloons at least one person would fight back. Maybe try saving, and going back, then 'targeting' (with your fists) all the people in the saloon one by one. At least one should fight back, and just knock him out.