User blog comment:Spawny0908/Character Disscusion: John and the Honor Meter/@comment-1600536-20111211010159/@comment-2113545-20111211212810

I played that way too my first time. John was good but Jack was so pissed so he went bad. I honestly don't know why people would want to be bad in red dead though, theres no benefit in being bad. If you're bad you get a shitty horse and cheaper prices in one town in the entire game but higher prices everywhere else. Whereas if you're good you get cheaper prices everywhere but one town, twice as much pay for jobs, and the duster coat. To be fair Rockstar could've added another outlaw town for bad players.