User blog comment:Rvb forever/What Red Dead Redemption 2 Got Wrong./@comment-37859107-20200116165743

The retcons and the continuity errors are definitely the most annoying ones. I would add the "John has never been to New Austin" thing as well. He mentions that to Bonnie in the first game. In the second game not only you get to free roam with him there (even if that isn't canon), but you have two missions taking place there - one with Sadie in Pike's Basin and one with Jeremy Gill in Rio Bravo.