Thread:Raziel Reaper/@comment-2008429-20190320204110

I've given this some thought and I think it might be advantageous to consider protecting and or locking the Marston Daughter page. Obviously with the release of Red Dead Redemption 2 this wiki has had a major boast in traffic, users and editors. Also with the release of Red Dead Redemption 2 we all thought that we would fianlly get to see John Marston's daughter and finally expand on her article. This didn't happen because she was never seen or mentioned in the entire game.

However since the release of the second game, a lot of users, mostly newer users on here have been attempting to fill the article with specualtion, theories on her wherabouts. If she was born between the Redemption games, etc and having to revert these edits, get into a minor edit war with these users about perserving the litle factual info we have on the article. Again and again. And the most annoying part is I know this will keep happening. Because people love to speculate on wiki pages where their is little to no information. People like to connect dots and offer explanations for things the games don't explain. At the cost of cluttering the article with specualtion. But this is something that can easily fixed by just simply protecting the page from edits.

And thing is, we were given no new information on John's daughter. Not since she was mentioned in 2010 with the release of the original Red Dead Redemption. It's been almost nine years and still nothing. The way the article is right now at this very instant, is literally the entire collection of confirmed factual knowledge on John's daughter. By protecting the page, you would not be stopping or slowly down users from adding more info, because their is no more new information to add. If you were to protect the page right now as it is, you would only be stopping fans from cluttering the article with specualtion. And I see no downside to that at all.

Anyways, that's my suggestion. Food for thought. 