Thread:Wagwan piffting23/@comment-38834301-20191214035829/@comment-38834301-20191214174241

The problem is that John is specifically mentioning Bill leaving him to die. In "An Appointed Time" Bill doesn't deny leaving John to die. Someone like Bill would definitely deny that, especially if he didn't actually leave John behind.

If Bill left John behind due to the fact he did not vounteer to look for John, then going by that logic, Arthur, Sadie, and Cleet also left John behind as well. In the epilogue, John doesn't mention Cleet leaving him to die, even though going by the above logic, he should. By contrast, he's angry at Joe, even if you try to defuse, likely because he was there when they actually left him to die. This suggests that he's aware of who left him to die.

John is a fair man, he's not going to accuse Bill of something he didn't do. It's clearly, in my opinion, a continuity error.