User blog comment:JackMarstonDiabloJr/Who hates the end of RDR/@comment-1265875-20110907155213

If nothing else, the ending is superlative in just the fact that you're upset by it.

John Marston is such a great character that you actually feel loss when he's gone.

That is truly remarkable for any media and virtually unheard of in video games.

I think that the reason we all like Jack so little is because we love John so much.