User blog comment:Spawny0908/A Red Dead Movie in the works?/@comment-1495666-20100826183715/@comment-1265875-20100826222904

If for nothing else, Brad Pitt having excellently played both Jeffrey Goines in 12 Monkeys and, of course, Tyler Durden in Fight Club, should never be labeled as a bad actor.

But yeah, I think he'd be terrible as John Marston.