User blog comment:Spawny0908/A Red Dead Movie in the works?/@comment-1265875-20100826180658

I think John Marston should be played by Bill Paxton.

Rob Wiethoff's voice reminds of Bill's in several places in the game, too...

And if you don't think Paxton can pull off drama or being ominous, definitely check out the flick called Frailty...