User blog comment:Willdog102/Red Dead Redemption./@comment-3992827-20110621113128

Yeah, it is one of the best. I really like a lot of 3rd person action games though...

Probably the order for me is: - Red Dead Redemption - Oblivion - Fallout 3 - L.A. Noire - Mafia II - Just Cause 2 - Fallout: New Vegas

This is kind of in the order of how much I play them. There's a few more games I like but these are the best. I know their all pretty different games, but I like the variety: Western, Apocalyptic, Dark Age, Mafia, Detectives, Secret Agent...

The thing that makes this game stand out among others is the gambling and hunting. I must've spent the first 20 hours of the game just hunting, selling the skins/meat, buying more ammo, then wasting the rest on Poker in Armadillo.