Thread:Raziel Reaper/@comment-38834301-20190908010643/@comment-2008429-20190909012525

While the "children" quote is vague. It's still Javier specifically mentioning John Marston's children. Children obviously being plural, meaning Jack and John's daughter. And while it might be very likely non canon now thanks to RDR2 that Javier ever knew John's daugher, it was still canon then when the first game released. The sequel did not contradict that until nearly a decade later.

John saying "someone new" isn't nearly as direct as Javier saying John's "children". Really, nothing about the RDR2 conversation implies John is talking about a possible daugher. He could just as easily be talking about Uncle or Charles. Who just recently in the story showed up on the ranch. You could really come up with a plausible explanation for just about any interpretation of it. It's that vague and brief.

That's just my two cents anyways. The admins will come up with a conclusion themsleves.