User blog comment:Lush1998/Uncle DLC/@comment-2011995-20111023004423/@comment-10278667-20111101235053

Robert Bogue, the voice of Red Harlow, is still alive, but I would not be happy to see Red's story continued. I think his story has been told, same as John Marston's, and it wouldn't really work to continue.

A DLC about Uncle's past would work, since he has an unknown background. Plus, from a moral standpoint, he seems rather neutral. He's not an angel, but he's definitely not a villain either. This works well with protagonists as the player doesn't feel like they need to be good or bad while playing. However, a lot of what makes Uncle an interesting character is his unknown background, and he doesn't seem to be the type that would have one of these amazing adventures, though it is a possibility.

All in all, if a new DLC were to be released, I would either like a new protagonist altogether, or a continuation of Jack Marston's story.