4,651
pages
ALL POSTSRDR1 Vs RDR2
<p>This question rips my soul apart buttt I like arthur a lot more than John</p>
Who do yall prefer John or Arthur?
John Marston
Arthur Morgan
63 Votes in Poll
0
I love them both?
<p>It's....I feel bad for John that Arthur is chosen above him so much and he's just ignored and underrated but...Arthur.</p>
<p>Me too i like em both</p>
Both good but I like red dead 2 more
I like rdr2 more
All the commentary the Arthur adds makes him a bit more likeable and also rdr2 adds a lot of depth to Arthur
John Marston is better than Arthur
<p>In red dead 2 Arthur just seems more wise and humble than john. not saying he is not but John's voice makes him sound too young and like a loose cannon. Where Arthur seems knowledgeable and thoughtful.</p>
Both of them