Now here me out guys, I am a believer that The Strange man is a Morally Grey God of Red Dead and GTA, now what I have always wondered why in the hell would they look so similar, now it could be fashion sense of fancy people, but I think it’s deeper

Let’s take Trelawny, the mustache and the top hat, and all, he looks rich, but unlike the stereotype he looks friendly, and trustworthy, like you would make a deal whether it be to good to be true, or not

What I’m referring to, is the Moon Deal, the deal with Herbert Moon, “I offered you happiness, or 2 generations, you made your choice.” I think this is a morally wrong deal

Because Herbert chose 2 Generations supposedly from the letter on his person. But it was to a Jewish father, making Herbert unhappy

Now if he chose happiness, I think what would happen is either, his daughter would have died, killing the first generation OR any man his daughter was to have a child with in the future would die, or simply she would become non fertile.

Either way, a man you can’t trust, is the man you would most likely trust, he’s testing the morals of humanity, and punishing the choices, the point

He is not a good God, he is not a bad Devil, or even Death

He is all of them, Red dead’s own Holy Trinity,

It’s a little fear thing rockstar added, to show the characters are minuscule in the grand scheme, a H.P Lovecraft type deal,

And that is the strange man, I’ll make an entire analysis in the future

Until then stay tuned for that analysis,