I think it should be based on the mafia age, where jack’s son can play as a gangster

But that's not red dead redemption, these games take place in the age of the west, it they went forward in time anymore it wouldn't be red dead

What I see it as is the red dead name is the name of the universe and the redemption or revolver is just the storyline it is following

I want that too! I'd love to play as arthur (or even dutch) during the start of the van der linde gang and how they got started. and it would be during the golden age of the wild west where outlaws and cowboys were at its peak. I hope if and when they make a red dead 3, it will be something like tht...

As much as i love jack, he's living in the time where outlaws and cowboys are fading and the mafia is becoming a thing. and that isnt very a red dead storyline at all.

I think that in the next Red Dead Redemption game you should play as G A V I N !!!

Me I love this idea