I’ve completed the main story at least 6 times, though I never kept a detailed count. I had always intended on doing a low honor playthrough, however every time I play I can never get myself to do it. So basically all of my playthroughs have been pretty identical, with the only exception that I end up finding a few more mission-specific notes and other items each time I play. Even with the playthroughs being identical, it still always feels fresh for me because the game just has such a great narrative.

I completed it twice just for the two high honor endings as much as I want to go low honor I really can’t bring myself to do it. Also what kept it fresh was there was always something I could have done differently

I’ve completed the main story 11 times now, 4 times honourable, and 7 times dishonourable. I have attained 100% Completion twice now, and my main save now is my 12th save. Now I just normally play Red Dead Online with my friends, since I’ve finished and all that. I still play story mode for fun and still some more random chance encounters.

I’m on my second play through (currently on chapter 2)

I believe I have completed the story 4 times

Second playthrough, now I have stopped at chapter 4

4 times

Iv completed the main story 6+ times too, I got 100% last year. N to keep it fresh roleplay or get 100% which is enuff to do until you come up with a new idea