I don’t particularly like Uncle. He doesn’t seem that interesting compared to some characters, and I also don’t find him very funny. He is also very different in the first and second game, which isn’t always believable.

Still, I do find speculation about previous events in his life interesting.

I see no value in the piece of skunk shit, he does nothing but harm the gang and should have been fed to alligators.

Since I already knew Uncle due to the first game, I knew he would be one of the survivors of the gang. In the second game, I didn’t like him in the first chapter due to how Arthur talked to him, like he was giving him the cold shoulder for a justified reason, especially since he calls Uncle ‘The Camp Rat’ in “Aftermath of Genesis”. Later on in the game, (Chapters 2-3) I started to like him more, Arthur starting to slowly involve him more and be a bit more open and accepting to him. Finally, in Chapter 4 and onward, this is when Uncle became one of my favourite characters. He may be useless, but he has a great personality, he’s enthusiastic, and overall just a hilarious character. So when he returned in the Epilogue, I couldn’t wait for what jokes and sarcasm he was going to use on John. Overall, Uncle is probably my 8th Favourite Character, after Charles, Josiah, Arthur, Dutch, Lenny, John and Sean.

Uncle is one of my favorite characters from the game, though I didn't focus on names when I started out so I don't really remember.

First in rdr 1 i thought he was a complete idiot, but in rdr 2 especially during the epilogue i found him quite entertaining with all his shenanigans.