No and only no.

No from me as well. I can’t see how they could make a third-person shooter video game out of that, so it’d probably be boring. I would prefer a prequel or a new story entirely.

I’d would like an Red Dead Redemption 3 sure, but I agree with Wagwan Piffting, a new story would be the best approach as I feel the story of the Van Der Linde gang for lack of a better term, has already been told.

But it would be nice to get a nod towards the previous 2 games if we were to get a new story for red dead redemption 3, like a newspaper article taking about the gang or somebody in a random encounter talking about the Saint Denis bank robbery or a former relative of Guarma explaining how some ‘mysterious Americans’ helped Hercule and the rebels to take down Fussar, or even someone who used to ride with Colm O’Driscoll or a former Pinkerton talking about hunting for Dutch’s gang and explains how the government tracked them all across the country (Providing that the third game would be set in the same universe)

but for that the game would have to be a sequel but even if it was a prequel Rockstar could still give nods towards the gang, Colm, Pinkertons etc

Rather OT but, speaking of Charles, I keep getting nudges to deliver eagle feathers to him, but he's already gone to Canada as far as I know (this is after a certain amount of vengeful bounty-hunting with him and Sadie). Is this a glitch or is there a way of meeting up with him again?

They shouldn’t call the game Red Dead 3, it should be called something else tbh if they’re going to make it another prequel. A game set after the events of Red Dead 1 would be boring in my opinion as after John’s death, the Wild West is over and Jack becoming an outlaw is like shitting on Arthur, John and Abigail’s graves as the last thing they wanted was Jack to become an outlaw.

There should not be another fucking prequel. I love the red dead series more then any other game, they do not need another prequel. It probably won't even be another redemption, it'll be red dead something else. With whole new characters and a whole new setting.

Maybe as a spin off. But I think there should be a new idea and protagonist explored.

Just a whole new story like a continuation of RDRevolver or maybe even farther back like post civil war in the 1870's or maybe even during the war just out west with minor conflicts

Honestly, that would be great. He was quickly one of my favorite characters in RDR2 and would love to explore him some more