Bill and Javier. They were fairly major in RDR 1, so it would’ve been nice to interact with them more and explore their relationship with John.

Charles was a good character and it would be fun seeing him get into more fights with more angry people

Javier. Out of the choices, though, Marco Dragic, because we only get two side missions with him (and one encounter, you know what.) Hamish is my favourite, but I feel we had enough missions with him. Same with Charlotte Balfour. Charles Chatenay was probably the most fun to do, and I wish you could receive more letters from him when he writes to you after he leaves America.

Marco

Hamish Sinclair could be Francis Sinclairs father or grandfather if the time traveller theory could hold up

I loved helping Charlotte how to survive in the wilderness besides her interactions with Arthur were grest, the two could have started a relationship if Arthur didnt have TB