Scenario: Dutch goes to confront Micah after realizing the coincidence of the Pinkertons showing up at both Blackwater and Saint Denis. they get into it and lose their guns leaving them to use knives and hands. (unstable post-concussion dutch is the current state of mind)
Hmm. Hard to say, as we never see Dutch in a fistfight. Micah is seen to be fairly mediocre in a brawl, but as he’s the younger man and more likely to fight dirty, I’d narrowly go for him.
@Thewherewolfman Well, in RDR1 he shot John with a pistol from a low angle from well over 100 feet away at such force that John fell over and was knocked unconscious, so I'd say he's a pretty good shot.
