I favour Double-action Revolvers, so out of all these, probably Micah’s Revolver. It also makes a good trophy for John to have. However, I also like Algernon’s Revolver a lot, perhaps even more - despite the power stat being slightly worse.
I like John’s Cattleman Revolver as well and always have it equipped when playing with John. It’s his old, trusty sidearm that never lets him down, so it’s good to use.
Although the M1899 is good, it’s a pistol, not a revolver.
Schofield Revolver in general is just my favorite. I had mine have a blackened steel and nickel body and a pearl grip with a buck engraving (an eagle engraving on the off-hand revolver), making it the direct invert of Micah's Revolver.
Although it’s a pistol, I love the M1899. I just got into Chapter 4 and I bought it and it’s awesome. The best thing I like about it is that it has a magazine so you don’t have big reload times.
