Definitely Saint Denis. Blackwater is fine, but I wouldn’t say it’s really anything special. Saint Denis is so massive and filled with stuff to do that it feels like it’s own region rather than Bayou Nwa. Also Saint Denis has Poker, while Blackwater has Blackjack, and for me that’s pretty much the deciding factor in it of itself.

Saint Denis is amazing huge and filled with life of course blackwater is filled with life too but saint denis is whole different level it has everything you need to but or craft from the dirty slums to fancy buildings saint denis has it all

Saint Denis is by far the best city in the game it has everything of latest modern technology(At the time period the game takes place) and great entertainment to provide lots of fun to the player, it has from good threatre shows, cinemas, luxurious bars, people playing music in the streets, trolleys, trains ect, overall is the best city in RDR2

Hey phoenixskull blackwater has poker too just so youre aware

I just wish black water would update at least in the epilogue. I love that saint denis has everything it’s like “going into town”, that’s the best town for that.

@Andy Balcazar Blackwater updates in the epilogue more than any other town in the game.

I prefer the city or Saint Denis, but I hate the swamps where it is located. Blackwater is less impressive, but I greatly prefer its location.

Hmm. I’d rather live in Blackwater and the surrounding area as I think it’s probably a nicer area. However, there’s more to do in Saint Denis as the player because of how big it is. I also like how similar it is to New Orleans, the tram network, the chimney smoke from industry... the devs certainly put a lot of effort into making it look the part, and I’d say they succeeded too. I like the well-developed police force in both too.

I want to see Saint Dennis get fire bombed.

Black water is not racist. unlike saint Denis