Dutch, before Chapter 5 he was a decent person and he managed to keep the gang together for 20 years. He’s also such an interesting character.

E

PEARSON cus hes so thick

Arthur Morgan

John Marston because it john

Arthur Morgan, for sure, a close runner-up is Lenny.

Probably pearson or uncle.

For me Charles is the best he is very honorable and loyal ?

Not including John and Arthur because they're protagonists, I'd say Dutch. He's such a complex character in my opinion, and you never know what he's going through or dealing with. Not to mention, Rockstar did an excellent job of showing his slow decent into madness after everything goes wrong in Saint Denis

John Marston of course. Dutch is my second favorite.