I hate to say it but it was Hosea for me

I'd say Hosea, because Sean's and Arturo's (the pilot's) deaths took me completely by surprise, and i didn't even realise Kieran was gone, because i was barely ever in camp, But with Hosea you can see him being held at gunpoint and then shot. Of course, i knew in a way that Sean and Hosea would probably die during the story because they weren't in Redemption (1), but then again, with that logic i also thought that at least Charles would die, which he didn't.

I had some spooky timing with Kieran's death. Right before I started that mission I was walking through camp and heard Mary Beth asking about where Kieran is, and I was like "Oh fuck, Kieran's in pieces right now isn't he?." Sure enough he turned up literally in pieces. Ever hate being right?

I expected kierans death because he just disrepaired

Sean made me jump out of my seat, but Kieran was scary as all hell I still expect Kieran to die bc only the player can go missing for a long time with no one noticing

I agree since he was the weakest member of the gang his death was the most expected because he wouldnt fight

Ah yes, the baloon piloet

How did you find this

Sean was overestimating himself.

But, I think Kieran's death was the most expected purely because of distrust because he was an O'Driscoll hired gun.

kierans death scared the shit out a me