Neither. Before rdr2 sadie was a rancher. After she goes to south america. Which kinda breaks the whole wild american vibe

As for jack, I don't think they could make a story with him that'd interest me. Maybe playing as young hosea/dutch but even that's a long shot

And you guys forget that rdr2 mad a masterpiece with some new character that was very relevant to john but had no mention in rdr1. They could do the same again. Or we could play as mac or davey, someone we heard of but never really get to see.

@Seddielover12 Fair enough lol

Sadie was just a rancher before rdr2. Also she is very annoying.

Neither its a prequel to rdr2 its hosea and its in 1870

Oh and the game ends at the blackwater massacre

Sadies Adler is not a good person.

@Dalepaton2006bb More likely we will play as Davey and/or Mac Callender possibly being able to switch between them like in GTA 5 or a new character entirely.

@LoreEnthusiast

How many of our protagonists have been good people? Their stories have been about redemption, after all.

Also, I find playing as the Callender brothers unlikely and the usage of the switch mechanic even less likely for the fact the R* had opted to not use for the Redemption series due to the different thematic approach.

I’d still say playing as a brand new character or at least one of the Callender brothers is most likely.

Also I just felt like saying Sadie Adler is not a good person because I’m tired of people thinking she’s cute and bad ass.

Spoilers????

She literally opens fire in to a crowd of random people after the Colm O Driscoll hanging.