I was so sad when Hosea died cause I loved his character and how he was the one of the morally good and straight thinking gang members ?

I thought Molly had the saddest part they had to burn her instead of just burieing her she was telling the truth and no one care to listen to her she tried to tell people things but they push her out of the way. no wonder she was talking to herself. no one listen to her.mg.?

It hit me hard like it hit authur when Hosea died where was Abigail at! when that happen .he told the truth about authur it's a trap .for authur but he got away from the o,driscos no matter what.take me home.and the horse did so.then dutch making up excuses also micha too.mg.

Honestly I've always wondered about that. How the hell DID Abigal escape the Pinkertons? Did she sacrifice Hosea? I dislike the character but I can't see her being that lowdown..

Davey Callander: I didn't feel anything as I didn't know him and hadn't seen him whilst he was alive

Sean MacGuire: I actually liked Sean so the first couple of seconds I stared dumbfounded at the screen then I raged and brutally murdered as many Gray's as I could. I found solace in the fact that I personally killed Leigh Gray and Archibald McGregor though

Kieran Duffy: Honestly I didn't think much of it I was surprised he was killed so brutally but I didn't see him much throughout the game.

Hosea Matthews: I was pretty upset that he died since he was like the grandfather of the whole gang and we did that legendary Bear mission earlier but needless to say I brutally murdered as many Pinkertons as possible.

Lenny Summers: This one truly rattled me, I loved Lenny, he was such an epic gamer and one of my favorite missions in the game, (the drinking one with him), had him in it. I also hated how Arthur seemed to be the only one who cared about him when he died.

Molly O'Shea: I didn't really like Molly honestly, she always was drunk and shrieking at Dutch. I don't think she deserved to die but I guess I didn't feel much for her when she died.

Susan Grimshaw: I liked Miss Grimshaw because she always acted cold but deep down she truly loved and cared about everyone in the gang a whole lot. I also hated how Javier distracted her just so Micah could cap her in the stomach. I wish Miss Grimshaw didn't die and I wish she escaped and lived a good life like John and Tilly.

Keiran’s death:my god

I haven’t played the first red dead yet but I’ve seen some things and Arthur and John’s death are tied for me as the saddest

Lenny and Hosea were beans that shouldn’t have been touched ?

Kieren’s (forgot how to spell it lol) death got me real sad, I loved him and I was so shocked at his death

When Arthur died i crying

Same

Davey- I didn't really feel any sort of sadness like I did with a few other character since he was only on screen for a split second in the beginning cutscene.

Sean- In my first playthrough, I was sort of shocked and sad at the same time because he was one of my favorite characters.

Kieran- I was sad and kind of hurt by this death because Kieran was one of my top 5 fave characters.

Hosea- I was saddened by this death

Lenny- I was also saddened by this death as well

Molly- At first, I thought she deserved it, but felt a little bit of guilt when I found out she actually wasn't the rat

Eagle- He wasn't one of the characters I ever payed attention to, but his death scene was sad

Susan- I wanted to stab Micah in the face after he killed her

Arthur- I cried during his last ride and his death scene(good honor, help John)

Micah- One word. Satisfying.

Javier- I tried to capture him alive, but accidentally killed him......oops

Bill- I wish he had a redemption arc and wasn't killed

Dutch- I found his story/fall down the wrong path sad and thought he could've went down a better path instead of following the legendary rat at the end of rdr2

Uncle- It was sad to see him go.

John- I played RDR1 before RDR2, so when John got killed, I was shocked, sad, and cried a little. It was very satisfying to kill Ross as Jack though.