I think you didn't add Eagle Flies to the list.

Added

Oh, and Uncle must be added to the list too.

Done.

Shouldn't this be marked as spoilers or something? Lol

But honestly I was hit really hard by Sean's death. Hadn't been expecting that one, and he was literally cut off mid sentence. Really fucking scarring if you think about it

Sean's surprised and saddened me

Lenny's upset me because it took me by surprise and there was no cutscene. It's as if you had no time to process it

Molly's was frustrating as it could have been avoided

Kieran's was sad but was badass to watch

Arthur's devastated me

I knew Arthur was coming even on my first playthrough, I had played the first one and I knew Arthur wasn't involved, and there's really only one way they could have kept that plot consistency, but r* did a phenomenal job developing a character that was destined for death and still managed to interest the player in their story arguably more than Marstons. His death was poetic and extremely well written.

Objectively speaking I would say Lenny probably IS the saddest death, as mentioned it happens outside of a cutscene, and yet is completely unpreventable. It caught me completely off guard and I honestly waited for the mission to fail at first before realizing what had happened. I was PISSED.

Tbh lennys death was the most sudden, it came out of nowhere Especially since he was young and probably one of the more morally good gang members.

Sean's death was......traumatic for me.????

You forgot Edgar Ross.