Honestly, I don't care about the Sadie Mary Sue anymore. I'm done with this.

@JeremiahE98 Here’s an explanation: John and Arthur have been outlaws for many years and used to death and killing, Sadie however lived on a farm and only start to kill in chapter 3. Then by chapter 6, she is now a full gunslinger which has only been a weeks or a couple of months at the most since the burning of her house.

Also if she live on a farm, what things did she shoot? There were certainly not lot of people and the only thing she could shoot are animals which doesn’t correlate with killing people.

One last thing is that if she was so tough as a farm hand. Why she couldn’t kill the o’Driscoll in her house. She did it later with just a knife in Shady Belle.

@TheHouseMaster Psst. You're forgetting that she was also out for blood. She wanted revenge, and wasn't against killing, because she turned cold and bitter. She took her training from hunting, and applied it to people. She was taught by her husband to shoot. You paid attention, right?

@TheHouseMaster Also, she was in shock at her husband's death, and surrounded by O'Driscolls. Last I checked, you can't kill a full house, in such in an enclosed space, with a knife. If she could do THAT, she'd be a Mary Sue.

Anyone remember when Sadie asked Arthur for help in defeating the O'Driscolls, gets captured later, and literally stabbed in the stomach? That definitely sounds like someone who can't do everything on her own. If she were perfect, she'd have that in the bag.

@JeremiahE98 come on you’re beating a dead horse, @TheHouseMaster just explained perfectly why she is a Mary Sue etc. it’s no need to simp this hard over Sadie.

@Catcher Wongus And I debunked that. You either give an argument, or not.

@JeremiahE98 this fandom isn’t about arguments, If you want to spend your time doing that i’m pretty sure it’s a comment section somewhere on YouTube where you’ll certainly enjoy yourself.

@Catcher Wongus What is this comment thread about, again?

Learning to shoot a gun on a farm against a few rabbits or something is a lot easier than shooting O’Driscolls. As Arthur says, it’s harder when they fire back. Sadie does not mention having much background in shooting apart from that, which is considerably less compared to other gang members. She also doesn’t mention anything about being “trained to kill”, nor would desire for revenge magically transform her abilities into something extraordinary.

Anyway, this discussion has gone on long enough and, as is usually the case when it comes to a divisive character like Sadie, is liable to becoming toxic. As a user mentioned above, this has lost its purpose and so it’s time to lock it.