Now people saying she “GoT FLawS” still doesn’t rule out a Mary Sue

I say she’s extremely over-hyped and not that good of a gun, she acts on nothing but impulse that endangers everyone around her at the time, cost that poor air balloon guy his life. Her whole cause contradicts the whole “revenge is a fools game”.

In my opinion

^ completely agreed on that. It’s sad that Rockstar broke their own code through the series, and in such an un-subtle way.

I think she is a Mary Sue who turned far too quickly from a helpless, grieving widow to an overzealous, all-guns-blazing hellcat who could wield a gun as well as other members of the gang with relatively limited experience in using one.

No, she's a Sadie Adler...

100% yes and only simps cant see her for the mary sue and badly written character she is

I don't really see her a Mary Sue sometimes but yeah for the most time, she's a Mary Sue. I'm not one of those who are absolute simps for her and also ship both her and Arthur. I don't understand that ship because Arthur doesn't really want another love in his life because of his fears of what happened to his previous family. Sadie wants to only be married to her husband Jake who she viewed as a good man and really doesn't want to get together with anyone else since she only loved her husband.

I think also that they tried WAY too hard to make her a female badass when I don't think they really needed to do that.

I wonder what’s the argument for people who put “no” as their answer.

A one eyed Micah would eat Sadie alive

I ask myself this question several times. I like her, but I think she can do a lot of things to perfectly.