There is little in the way of concrete evidence that Dutch ever meant well genuinely.

Bill went on to become an arsonist, mass murdering rapist without dutch keeping him in check..

Micah had the worst influence on the gang, especially Dutch. Apparently he persuaded him into killing Heidi McCourt according to John, and that was near the start of the game.

Dutch

Joe And Cleet i don't think they are a members they are just A Associate for the train Robbery

ALWAYS MICAH

Michah is a no good backstabbing little bully im so happy he was killed of he is the worst rockstar antagonist

Dutch was tricked by the rat

I don’t see Cleet and Joe as a gang member

Bill seems to me to be the laziest and biggest jerk.