Be honorable next time

Ik

I personally didn't like or hate Arthur, but I felt weird when I was playing as Marston, probably because I spent alot of time with Arthur.

The bad ending is just horrible

Its called redemption for a reason and the bad ending betrayed Arthur's whole arc

Dude you made a dumb mistake doing the low honor ending and going back for the money for your first playthrough. The high honor ending means so much more and it fits Arthur way more, the game is called redemption for a reason. Also, you probably won’t be as emotional once you do actually finish a high honor playthrough, since you already know Arthur does.

Yes I know I shouldn't have done it I was naive and didnt know about the honor meter until CHAPTER 6 so yeah I screwed up but I returned to the mission because I didnt save and went with john and micah killed arthur by gunshot I will retry again this time with high honor but I have a second xbox account called animegojira and I have high honor

@Johnny Potatoman I'm sorry I was naive but I will retry on my second xbox account as high honor

The BEST ending in RDR2 is to help John and beat Micah with High honor is the only ending scenario in which Arthur is not Killed by Micah instead he dies of TB and hipotermia

Oh so why does john get revenge on micah if micah didnt kill arthur

@Gojirablade7339

Micah beat Arthur to a pulp. Thats the same as killing him.

And on low honor he shoots Arthur in the head