It's a great idea. I think North Grizzlies would make more sense than Canada up top, though. Arthur even mentions the gang spending the 1898 winter over there in his journal. Some of the Canada part you designed could be replaced with North Grizzlies and the other half could be a new state. I'm not an American and I hardly know about its geography but this makes more sense imo.

Yes I was supposed to do North Grizzlies too but idk how I forgot.

Great idea, but 1. What time zone would it be set in

2. I don't think any computer, pc, or console would manage tohandle this

3. It would take probably years to create this

1. Probably different timezones, didn't think of that so it might be tricky

2. The PS5 and Series X might, later in their life cycle. If RDR2 could run perfect on a 2013 console, a game of this scale can easily run on a PS5/Xbox Series X or a High end PC of the future

3. Yeah, but let's not forget, 8 years is what gave us the masterpiece Red Dead Redemption 2

Too big