I’ve played the first game a while ago, but don’t remember much, but now you mention that I have heard someone post that before in the uncle theory lol.

Yeah I know this is a bit outlandish because the only evidence I have to go off of is that John and Red look similar and that John’s mother was a prostitute but that’s really the only evidence I have

Don’t get me wrong, it’s an interesting theory. Better than the uncle one anyway ha

Definitely and it’s more believable like how can you think Uncle is Red where’s his scars? Where’s the burn on his hand? And most importantly where’s his scorpion revolver?

Up his ass, that’s what his lumbago really is

Red Dead Revolver takes place in the 1880’s and by 1885 when Dutch found John when he was 12, John said his father was blinded in a bar fight and he also says his father was born on the boat from Scotland. So no, Red Harlow is not John’s father.

Yeah that’s true but while we don’t know Red’s exact age we can guess that he’s at least in his 30’s as by the time we play as him in game he’s a very experienced bounty hunter and yes John says that his father came over from Scotland but like I said the man who we believe is John’s father is implied to have been John’s mother’s pimp so i’m saying that MABYE Red came through a town where John’s mother was working and knocked her up that’s all i’m saying feel free to disagree but it’s possible is all I’m getting at

Are you saying that Uncle could be Johns father??? (I’m joking)

Very funny

Yeah I’ll show myself out 😅