I think it should but it should be a prequel to RDR1 not RDR2 like it should be in 1908 or 1909

Maybe as Jim Calloway or Landon Ricketts? Or maybe just the gang at early start leading to the "Shit that happened in Blackwater."

Yeah, i defo want rdr3 to happen, i dont want rdr2 to turn into gta and gta o, where the games been out for almost a decade and no updates for story mode, also i want rdr2 online to die, in a way where if the game has turned into a wild west gta, people would stop playing it so rockstar knows we arnt playing around.