To be perfectly honest no. In the Pt 1 Epilogue she was always pissed at John even in the times where he really had no choice or he really was doing his job at defending Pronghorn Ranch. I understand why she was mad, because she doesn’t want him to die and she wants a family life with him with zero violence. But nonetheless in Pt 1 she should’ve been more understanding. The only time I feel her being pissed was justified was John, Charles, and Sadie going after Micah, because like it’s been said in the game, Revenge is a fool’s game. AND, John killing Micah is what led to the Pinkertons finding him and his family, leading to the events of RDR1. Other than that though, no personally don’t believe she was very justified for all the times she’s been pissed at him. Over half the stuff that took place wasn’t even his fault in the first place.
