^Thankya kindly, ma'am! Thankya kindly!

I think he was probably full of gas as well, but I still love 'im!

I probably should just leave theories to other ppl :/

@H. Roosevelt Yeah now that I think about it, I was so stupid when I did this theory, it's just that I was so happy thinking that I had noticed something cool and I actually didn't. I have a some theories and most of them are bad, so with this one I thought that I was 80% right. Oh and I thought that the "irrelevant" part actually meant irrelevant because english ain't my main language and sometimes I don't understand what a person is telling me.

Yeah, I'm pretty sure the "one-shot kid" nickname isn't referring to his skills with a revolver.....

^^No, don’t say that! Theories like this are great; they get people together, they get them talking, they get them sharing opinions. If no one shared their opinions/theories around here, things would be pretty boring. Even if the theory’s implausible, it still generates conversation and that’s important. It keeps a fandom going. Never be afraid to share your opinion, even if it’s the “wrong”/“unpopular” one.

^

Agreed, I hadn't intended for my posts to come off as disparaging. My main point is the fact that Uncle's life as in outlaw is known, he just shows he is and wasn't likely a very good one. Per Aragorn, theories are interesting to discuss, examples should just hold more weight when being lended to a theory itself.

No hard feelings on the confusion on my use of "irrelevant" either, it's understandable. My wording with it probably could've used a bit more clarification anyways.

@Gold Master308

@Aragorn Skywalker Of House Stark

Thanks but I'll just keep updating the spanish version of Red Dead wiki, it's pretty outdated and I'd like to keep ppl informed with the updated info of this version.

I already changed Red Harlow's page, it was kinda funny still seeing the 2012 version saying "There's a popular rumor going around the internet about him being actually a character from Red Dead Redemption, Uncle......". Also mentioning that Red possibly died in a shootout with Landon Ricketts in 1896.

There’s an old theory that he is actually Red Harlow, pretty interesting one, but unlikely.

@Peavee

I'd say it's pretty interesting to anyone who ignores even the most basic evidence that suggests that's not the case. The theory itself is only upheld by those who have dedicated having a chip on their shoulder specifically for it. However, it's outright pointless when you take into account the fact that it's nullified since the events of Revolver are officially non-canon to the Redemption saga.

Even as a middle aged man Uncle was on his prime hes is a very expenrienced, humble and good hearted outlaw hes way more useful than Swanson, Molly