Better character, Dutch.

Better person, Hosea

@Darth Joako I agree. I clicked Hosea but instantly regretted it. As you said, he was a better person than Dutch, but in terms of character, I feel it’s impossible to have an opinion on him. There are only a handful of missions where you see Hosea or even talk to him for that matter, so we don’t learn a lot about him.

I still say Hosea because he was that voice of reason we all knew had to die. The Braithwaites were fun missions with him too. But Dutch is pretty flat. He is simply a sociopath. Extremely manipulative and no remorse for the acts of violence (explains them as necessary), and an immense sense of self-grandiosity when reality they have no clue what they’re doing (people question you when they see you failing, don’t bitch Dutch, quit failing and they stop doubting), and the plan that’s just “perfect”. Hosea along with Arthur to an extent kept that bit of Dutch in check but the Blackwater job going terrible made it impossible for them to do that. Still a good character, but sociopathic characters are very predictable. He was fine and everyone loved him at first but Blackwater was where it went wrong and the first hint you’re dealing with a sociopath is how they respond to personal failure. Hosea was everything Dutch pretended to be.

Dutch went through the most development

I really liked Hosea because he was the calm, comforting father figure the entire gang had and was the only one who protect Dutch form that rat micah, (I cried when he died)