You mislabeled the Volcanic as the Semi Auto, and the Semi Auto as the Volcanic.

My mistake, I would say just vote for the name over the picture

Anyway, out of these, I'll go with the Cattleman. The semi automatic pistols use up ammo very quickly, and they don't have much power. The Volcanic is too slow. And the Double Action is very inacurate.

I run double navy revolvers

Personally i use the LeMat, but as it aint up here i went for the cattleman as i just love it.