I don’t have the game anymore but I kept Arthur’s default attire and clean shave. Didn’t ever change him that much.

When I got to John I dressed him like how he is in RDR1

This is my John's outfit. I'm in love with the exotic hat.

Cool

I leave Arthur’s beard as long as it’ll grow, with basically the default shirt and stuff. I keep his normal hat on and wear…I forget what it’s called. The Hunter Jacket or something? It’s black with a little brown collar. Also, I gave him work pants. Sometimes, when I’m feeling goofy, I put the Bear Head Hat on, or the Mountain Fox Hat.

I try to keep John’s beard somewhat short and I just leave him in his default uniform, except I put on Arthur’s hat for missions.

I honestly just really really REALLY love the Gunslinger outfit and his default hat for Arthur. It just think it fits his character so well I just love the way it looks. I changed it a little bit, different pants, different color boots, replaced the neckerchief with a bandana, and added the Native accessory for his Gambler hat, along with the Upgraded gunbelt, bandolier, and holsters with the Legend Of The East satchel.

Arthur and John. I keep the styles relatively similar, as i really like the style, even my Red Dead Online character is quite similar lmfaoo. Yeah so, commonly a nice hat, the Shotgun coat, some clean shirt, a necktie of some sort, fancy pants and Wingtip gaiters. I also prefer Long hair and a moustache for the characters. This time i also gave arthur a little beard, it's a bit overgrown in that picture, but it's just simply an amazing picture.