John’s in RDR1 looks so much better than in RDR2. They made the shirt white for some reason instead of cream. And the vest looks different too.

John's is just the classic, which is why people love it so much, myself included.

My vote goes to Red Harlow.

Jack in my opinion

Red Harlow's outfit is clean as hell. Jack's is pretty good too.

I might be a little biased of Arthur but I think his outfit perfectly shows his personality.

I like Jack's outfit. I'd like John's a bit more if he had Jack's black pants. I don't like how they made his hat leather in RDR2, and I hate Arthur's hat.

"I hate Arthur's hat."

Blasphemy.

It's made of dried, cracked, scuffed up leather. It looks terrible. It would be uncomfortable to wear. No one would wear a hat like that, and no one does wear a hat like that.

It’s his dad’s hat, you idiot