He’s the comedian of the gang that thinks he’s acting all tough, and I love him for that. I also love Uncle, the gang comedian who is fully aware of being one. Lumbago.

He’s a dickhead, simple

I think he just grew up the hard way, which he truly wasn't meant for, and it resulted into him never wanting to show signs of weakness/affection in general. But if he would've been treated fairly, I think he would've turned out really nice.

I do also think that the homophobia stuff in the army must've not helped either :/

(though he had a crush on Kieran, and he had fun playing with Cain 🐶 so... yep he does have a soft side)

I thought he was pretty funny in rdr2. But in rdr1 he’s a dickhead

He was adorable in some moments of RDR2 like the ones Wintergel mentioned but unfortunately he has a weak mind, similar to that of Dutch, which led to his eventual corruption.

He's the one character in camp I love to antagonize.