Honestly? Yeah probably Red, no? I mean I can’t say that I’ve played Revolver but I will say- given the different format from Redemption, I’d believe you if you told me that Red preforms more amazing feats than Arthur or John (not to mention Red has a much more limited skill set than Arthur or John, who both know how to herd cows and gamble what whatnot) so that makes Red more of a focused gunslinger than a Jack of all trades, like Arthur or John.