That's a hard decision but I feel Sadie would win

Sadie wouldn't stand a chance against Dutch 💀

She's hardcore overrated and people seem to forget how much of a great shootist and gunslinger Dutch is...

I don't really want any harshness but when I had the game bought for me in '18 I kinda had a crush on Sadie so I chose her.

We all had a crush on Sadie. No judgment here.