When you ask the average gamer, "What is the worst chapter of Red Dead Redemption 2?" you may get some mixed answers, but the one chapter that will be stated more than the others is Chapter Five, the Guarma chapter. The Guarma Chapter is rather disliked by the community for its very weird position in the storyline and how it fits into the story like an obese passenger on an airplane seat. It is also criticized for underutilizing its main setting: the island of Guarma, along with underutilizing antagonists that had a lot of potential, such as Alberto Fussar and @Levi de Santa- I mean Levi Simon.
Anyways, even though Ch. 5 is a hot mess in a lot of ways, it is also pretty damn good in other aspects. You see Dutch's descent to madness and the heightened feeling of "Where the hell am I?" and "I want to get the hell out of here." You're literally put into Arthur's thoughts. Then again, the chapter also sticks out like a sore thumb because of this. This is why I am revising Chapter Five, adding new missions, storylines, locations, and characters. I'm keeping the good parts and improving on the bad parts, all of it being on this blog post I made!
https://reddead.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:Leprechaunlauch/Fixing_the_Guarma_Chapter
Keep in mind that this is entirely conceptual, and I will also be adding other elements that were cut from the original Guarma island (back when it was originally known as Guama); this includes towns and landmarks and utilizing the sheer massive size of Guarma (the actual island is massive). I've made custom mission titles, plots, and more for each mission in this revised chapter, so I hope you read this!
P.S.: I copied most of this from my intro in the blog post because I'm lazy as hell and I'm tired. But give feedback on the blog post, voicing your praise or concerns!