Always play as high honor Arthritis Mortgage

Who is arthritis mortgage? Don’t you mean apathetic milestone?

There is no canon ending to this game but you are given the choice of being either a hero or an absolute psychopath but I'd say get John to safety high honor is the choice everyone makes.

Remember that casino mission in 2019 for GTA Online? We found that option C was the canon ending for GTA V but RDO is set in 1898 so we don’t know the canon ending for RDR2.

I read somewhere that high honor/getting John to safety is canon, but don't recall where. Take that for what you will. I honestly could never bring myself to do a low honor playthrough. It just feels wrong to me.

I thought his name was Adventure Morningstar

I’ve never been able to play evil Arthur past the point where you have the choice to save the guy dangling off the cliff in Chapter 2. The game is so realistic feeling that I find it too disturbing to be evil. At least so far.

And also Arthur just doesn’t feel evil to me. Not in the cold blooded sense anyway.

Maybe I’ll try again to play evil Arthur for my next play through. Maybe I can succeed at it if I’m not a purist. Maybe a middle of the road Arthur. I dunno.

@Nomad416 same. Arthur just doesn’t seem like some sadistic psychopath. He can do what he believes he has to do but he takes no pleasure in hurting others.

Actual psychopaths in the gang would be: Dutch, Micah, Cleet, Joe, Sean (he chatted and joked with that plantation worker on the carriage one moment and then didn’t hesitate to kill him in cold blood the next)…I’m not sure about Bill.

I think pretty much everyone else has some level of empathy and believes/believed/wants to believe in Dutch’s Robin Hood BS.