Only nitpicks are, Pearson was in the navy and could defeat Tilly and Micah could defeat Sean and Sadie. Apart from that the rank is still good (could be wrong I haven’t played rdr1 but I think Jack also has dead eye so he could technically beat a lot of these folk)

Jack would win because none of the gang members have cheat codes allowing them to attack Jack. Jack is God in this game. Also I only realized this mught be the only kid(less than 17 at least) that I have seen in a rockstar game in like who knows when.

Arthur would kick that little shit off a cliff