They're both only bad if you make them have low honor. Yes, they're outlaws, but they couldn't help it. They were basically raised by Dutch and his gang, so they had to be loyal to them in return.

@The Ffidyller Exactly!

Whoever wrote this didn’t understand the game

@Big fan of Agatha investigations I found the comment under a yt short

Arthur's a bad man, high honor or low honor.

No matter how high they're honor is, yes with all they've done they might never be fully be redeemed but I wouldn't go as far to say what this fella said 💀