John is but we see Jack grow up into adulthood so both John and Jack, but it started with John.

Would it turn your world upside down if I were to tell you that Dutch is the main character and Arthur and John are secondary characters in his ballad?

@MadMikeRyan i don’t know what to respond with

If you consider the context of the original release of RDR1, it's John's story, but RDR2 does allow for another prequel game where we see how Dutch started the gang, making the final lore Dutch's story.

Uncle

In the first it is John then jack but in rdr2 it is author than John so idk

It's the Marston's story, we just see it through many eyes.

I can agree because it was a marston in the end of both games