Schofield revolver pistols are my favorite pistols and sidearms so try those

I use dual LeMat revolvers in Online, but I would use the Semi-Auto Pistol if enemies actually dropped pistol ammo and it wasn't just a bunch of running to the post office every 5 minutes, or after every firefight. We need to not have ammo issues in RDR2, like just double the capacity and then double it again just to be safe.