For me, last proposition, because in Chapter 2, she sometime spawns from nowhere and yells at me “NOT NOW!!!!”

I mean from RDR she was a great character even, though Her & Uncle don't have many missions, Her chemistry with John has both humorous and heartfelt moments. As for RDR2 at first I was taken aback by her personality, only to understand throughout the story that she is mostly a single mother surrounded by outlaws, as She focused on Jack's well-being. Then as for the Epilogue, She is caught in the middle of trying to protect a now 12 year old Jack ,while doing her best to make family life work with John without, being tied to their past life as outlaws.. All of these events make me understand why sure as overbearing as Abigail can be at times, She's doing it solely from good intent to protect her family ,and the better Life that Arthur worked so hard to ,help them secure, Rather than back peddling into their past outlaw lifestyles.

She cares too deeply for her family and friends. I get it but stop nagging.

Saintgliso Valid Point Arthur did write in his journal over the many times John & Abigail would argue, even before the Blackwater Massacre. It is nice to see how 4 years at Beecher's Hope mellowed her out.

She lost my empathy when she refers to Jack as "my son" instead of "our son" when she's talking to John.

@Davdsd

John was still questioning if Jack was his as late as Chaper 2.

@H. Roosevelt

What I feel about Abigail is something that I am not able to express in words or even in writing, but I think you will be able to get an idea.

She's great 😃

She’s great, in RDR2 doing everything she can for Jack. Begs Arthur to go look for John in the beginning eventhough John at the time is an asshole who only recently rejoined them and still doesn’t take responsibility for Jack and treats her bad. She’s also tough, and sees through Dutch’s bullshit and does Milton in. Through the main story and epilogue all she does is to protect her family. And if John had done as she begged and not gone after Micah they wouldn’t gotten on Ross’ radar.