It’s been five years of Red Dead 2. I enjoyed playing this game so good.
It should be a spinoff with 2 campaigns. 1 campaign is Charles Smith, the other is Sadie Adler.
The game title is Red Dead: Stories
206 Votes in Poll
250 Votes in Poll
281 Votes in Poll
288 Votes in Poll
It’s Black History Month and Fandom is celebrating by highlighting the impact black artists, authors, actors, musicians (and more) have on the media many of us all enjoy!
Check out this blog post for more on that!
On top of that, Fandom is hosting chat/text based roundtables in our official discord to discuss and share more franchises.
The upcoming roundtable for videogames will be held on: Tuesday, Feb 22, 12PM ET / 6PM CET
Everyone is welcome, and this is a great opportunity to discuss characters such as Charles, Lenny, and Tilly as well as celebrating the talent and creativity of black game devs, voice actors and more, so please feel free to stop by!
I'm sorry if I offended some of you who wants a Charles in Canada or Sadie in South America DLC, but I don't think it would work for RDR2. If it was a story like a book or something, then that would work, but as a DLC for a videogame? I don't think so.
As much as they are beloved by all, they wouldn't work as protagonists like Arthur or John. Sure, it is unfair to even compare Charles and Sadie as protagonists to John and Arthur. But still, they wouldn't work.
Charles was a very awesome character in RDR2. He is a silent and tough type who is a hunter. You don't think much about him at first, but when you get through him and talk to him, he is actually a good and kind person who kills when he has to and does bad things simply because he's an outlaw and they are on the run. He soon pretty much makes you love him when he shows his loyalty to you and Arthur and also John later on in the game. While he fits as a main character, he doesn't fit as a protagonist. He doesn't have the depth of character that John or Arthur does.
Same thing goes for Sadie as well. Sadie is a tough, ruthless and vengeful bounty hunter and gunslinger who stops at NOTHING to get her revenge. But you see that she's a good person who is in grief after her husband was brutally murdered. But is she playable protagonist material? No.
Again, I'm sorry. I love Charles, and while I have issues with Sadie, I still enjoy and like her. But they aren't fit or perfect to be protagonists.
I know that back then before RDR2 was released, everyone didn't like Arthur and thought he wouldn't even be better than John. And you know what happened after the game was released and you spent time with him in the game. But you see, Arthur was ALWAYS going to be the protagonist of the game, ever since the development of RDR2 began around 2011.
Don't @ me. I'm just stating my opinion. If you disagree, that's fine. I'm not going to enforce my opinion on you.
SPOILER WARNING
What is the name of Micah's Gang? ALSO why is Dutch one of Micah's goons? Or is Dutch and Micah co-leaders?
319 Votes in Poll
I played few replays and every time the varnish changed to this white version instead of the reddish varnish.
They're the best two fist fighters in the gang. Who do you think would be better in a scrap? Do you think Arthur would've been able to handle himself in the ring that Charles was in in 1907?
Overall, Arthur is probably a bit more experienced, but Charles seems to be bigger and clearly has ample ability to take care of himself in the wild. Hard to call.
I was in beechers hope doing farming work in the epilogue to get my honor up, but suddenly Charles was doing farm work as well, I thought he had went to Canada after Johns wedding. Anyone have any clue what happened?
155 Votes in Poll
Charles is just such a dope character and I feel like they missed out on his development and making him into even more of a badass. Let me know what you guys think of Charles.
You have to wonder. Did they really make it? Charles Smith supposedly went to Canada. Sadie also is implied to have left the country. Did they escape the Bureau of Investigation backed by Nate Johns in 1911? Is it plausible that Edgar Ross killed them? We never get full confirmation that they actually made it. So it is left somewhat ambiguous. But you could also argue that Rockstar put that dialogue in the game to basically tell the player "Yes, Ross didn't kill Sadie or Charles they left the country." Also, what about Pearson, Mary Beth, Tily, etc. They likely survived or were never even hunted given that they never took on law enforcement or robbed banks.
Personally I think Sadie is one of the more likely to be alive. Given that she was able to have a successful career as a bounty hunter out west and was never ever hunted by the law. Charles Smith on the other hand? Less likely. Given that 1907 newspapers mention the law is aware he is on the loose. Also the last we see of Charles is him returning to Beecher's Hope shortly after the end of the game (in a random encounter). So it's possible he didn't get very far and never made it to Canada.
Pearson was likely never hunted. Nor Mary Beth because they never participated in any crime. Or at least, as far as law enforcement would know about. Tily Jackson however has a criminal past and even the Foreman Brothers were looking for her right before the gang fell apart. So you could assume that logically law enforcement is likely to be as well.
So if I had to give it my best guess as to who is alive by 1911...
Sadie is still alive because law enforcement never hunted her in the first place.
Charles is the most likely out of the surviving members to be dead. Given that the newspapers mentioned him being wanted alongside John, Micah, Javier, Bill and Dutch. Even if he did make it to Canada, moving to another country isn't enough to escape the Bureau. That didn't go very well for Javier.
Pearson is alive due to a lack of notoriety.
Mary Beth is alive due to a lack of notoriety.
Trelawney apparently went back to a normal life in Saint Denis. He is still alive by 1907. Given that you can hear him with his family in the city even after Arthur's death.
Tily is likely alive but she may still be wanted for the murder of Malcom Foreman among other past crimes we don't know about. Slightly reducing her chances of still being alive in my eyes.
So what's your opinion? Share your thoughts.
I know we all love the idea love the idea of a rdr3 set as a prequel about the gangs formation but what about a game where you play as charles where he starts his family in Canada. Thoughts?
This is set just before Abigail dies, and Jack is working outside the Ranch, he hears a gun shot and finds Abigail Dead, she had committed suicide because she couldn’t cope with the death of John, Jack is mortified and majorly saddened, so he buries her and goes after Ross. 1 year after Agent Rosses death, and Sadie visits. She enters the Ranch to Jack gone. She’s confused because there is no Uncle, no Jack, no Abigail and no John.
She searches the ranch and finds johns grave, along with Abigails.
She bursts into tears and searches for Jack. He is no where to be seen so she asks a local. He says that Jack is Canada. So Sadie goes to Canada.
She searches everyday and asks everyone she could find and eventually finds him. He is with some Native Americans, Rains Fall and Charles Smith.... You finish the idea, share your comments below....
260 Votes in Poll