Dutch's Gang

1. Who is the stupidest character in the entire game of Rdr2?

2. Who is the stupidest character in the entire gang of Dutch’s in Rdr2?

So how was Cornwall one step ahead of them on many occasions BEFORE Micah started ratting.

I have collected some evidence that says it could have been John and Abigail.

Im not 100% certain on them being rats.

But remember, John eventually retires from life of crime, becomes a bounty hunter, and goes after the remaining members including Dutch him self.

So would this really be that surprising?

Putting Forth Oil, Train robbery mission

this train robbery was Johns idea. After Arthur agreed to rob this train John said he has to run in to town for Abigail and before finishing his sentence and giving Arthur a chance to question what he just said he stresses “DONT EVEN ASK” (we never got an explanation for what they were doing there) I think he was going back to tell the Law that Arthur will go through with this train robbery so they can set them up.

The Law showed up real fast and John was the one who pointed that out.

The Sheep and the Goats

Cornwall knew from John that the gang was going to be in Valentine. Then they took John Marston as a hostage to play it off.

Saint Denis Bank Robbery

Abigail and Hosea were supposed to do a distraction while the rest of the gang robs the bank. What happened next? Abigail and John literally disappear and Hosea got executed.

I think she went and snitched before they robbed the bank, John snuck out and surrendered as soon as things got crazy and the whole robbery could have been a set up to go bad by the Marstons.

When John was in jail it was just bait to lure Dutch, but Dutch never showed up to save him instead it was Sadie and Arthur. So they immediately gave up on that plan and let John return to the gang once more.

When John was shot in the final train robbery the Pinkertons found him lying on the ground and said “Hey! Thats our informant!”

picked him up, patched him up and sent him walking right back in to Dutches camp.

Remember? “You left me!”

How else would he have gotten back to the camp after being shot in the chest and with no horse?

I don’t think this is 100% true but there is certainly some evidence.