So I tried looking on the wiki to see what I was doing wrong but I can't find anyone who is having my problem. In the mission "Who is not without sin" everything goes according to plan right until I have to stop the guy from getting the law. I catch him, threaten him, and he says ok and runs off...but the law is ALWAYS right there and the Reverend never walks on the bridge. I've tried everything from choking the dude out to pointing my gun, and the psychic lawmen are always right there.
There hasn't been once where I didn't catch the guy and stop him, the reverend just never walks on the bridge and I think that's what triggers them. Has anyone come across this?
Keep in mind I'm on PC.