Hamish Sinclair

Arthur Morgan

Hamish Sinclair

Buell

If this post reaches 10 likes, I will try to make more

The death of Arthur's horse is sadder than Arthur's death, change my mind. Usually, I don't care for horses in rdr1, but in rdr2, goddammit, they're so realistic and loyal to Arthur that I can't even play the final mission without at least getting goosebumps.

I mean, come on. Rockstar even had to add the detail of the horse crying as it reaches closer to death. And Arthur comforting his loyal steed... damn it, Rockstar, why do you have to make endings in the red dead redemption franchise so sad?

Of course, I am biased. For two reasons:

1. I love horses

2. I get upset over silly things. In mid-2023, a friend gave me a birthday card because it was my birthday, and once I opened it, I immediately started crying. It doesn't make sense how I cry over a fucking piece of paper and not cry over the saddest video game death in history.

If I ever complete the game with Buell, I probably will cry because he's my favorite horse in the game and I feel like I'd let Hamish (my favorite character) down if I killed basically his best friend.

Unfortunately I forgot to save the game after I got him. Does rdr2 save after the last Hamish mission or do I have to start over? 😭

So when i was playing red dead 2 i wanted to do all the optional honor missions on chapter 6 so i did all 4 hamish sinclair missions and the other ones but that one was my favorite and i failed to save buell and it hurt me so i robbed his house and lit it on fire since hes dead and then i threw a molotov i heard some voice say "what the" and i was like what the hell? Then i realized not much npcs spawn near o'creaghs run so whats really going on does he actually have a ghost?

Is it possible that Hamish Sinclair (the veteran) and Francis Sinclair (the possible time traveler) could be related?

Quick question. In the stranger side mission the Veteran Part IV after Hamish is gored by the giant boar and he dies, and John/Arthur kills the wretched beast can the player keep Hamish's hat if he picks it up? It's a nice hat. I have a funny feeling that you can't.