Missable Content in Redemption 2

It's been three or seven weeks since I finished RDR2's story mode, and I still think Chapter 3 and Chapter 5 are the best.

Like many others, I felt a bit disappointed when we went from being a most-wanted outlaw in five states to a family man. I really regret not using the time when Abigail and Jack left John to tackle side missions, like searching for dinosaur fossils.

With that in mind, I've decided to replay the game, but this time I'll approach it differently and make better use of my time than I did during my first playthrough.

Do you have any recommendations for my second playthrough? Quick and easy ways to make money? Tips on leveling up Arthur's attributes faster? Any advice would be appreciated!

Looks like the beta took place in the fall while the final took place in the spring.

This was from RDR2 trailer 1 released back in 2017

I just noticed something on my fifth rdr2 play through the German guy we save in the end of chapter 2 his name is Andreas can he be the same guy as in rdr1 the German gambler Andreas Muller or are they different

I just went to Mr Wrobel's place and realized I can parkour my way into his barn (just jumped through the window) and I find this rare-lookin special horse that has white hair, and an amazing color. Is it rare? Should I wait till epilogue to go get it or will it be gone? do I have to go back to my recent save so that I never entered the barn just to be sure it wont despawn if I leave? thanks if you read this

-

Tre

I found a shack in the game but it appears to be unmarked on the map. It's near emerald ranch and it has flowers on top of it.

Map location

Outside of the shack

Inside

Does anyone know how to complete the stuipd Poisonous trail map in the cave, I cant

When playing as Arthur, I had collected a total of 17 gold bars and never cashed them out, thinking they would be gifted to John in the epilogue. Well I lost quite a bit of stuff I collected as Arthur, including the gold. Is it still possible to retrieve the lost gold by redoing the treasure hunts or is it just lost forever?

The evidence suggests that jack marston is the rat and he was sending messages to the pinkertons via his dog "cane".

As I am sure most fans who have completed RDR 2 are aware, Edith and Archie Downes are featured in a cutscene during the end credits that shows how their lives have improved by the time of the Epilogue.

However, I am unsure whether or not this is only the case for those who completed the game with high honor and completed “Do Not Seek Absolution I & II”.

In my first playthrough, I went through most of Arthur’s storyline and ended it with low honor, and to my personal recollection, I do not remember seeing their cutscene in the end credits of that playthrough. As such, I assumed it was naturally omitted since I had low honor throughout Chapter 6 and the “Do Not Seek Absolution” mission strand was therefore unavailable to me.

Can anyone who has completed a low honor playthrough confirm this is actually the case?

If any of you know any good points of interest, easter eggs, missions, encounters or other things that can help me get to 100% or something just for fun, let me know. I do have good knowledge about a lot of the game but I still need to know things I missed. I am currently at 85.5% finished. Thanks!

Also here are some cool minifigures of Rdr1 John I made. I am also a LEGO fan.

Ijust played Dominoes and happened to play with Tilly, so.. update her item request? :P

So I’m on my second play through…and for the second time I stupidly failed to hogtie the dude near Diablo Ridge that has this first treasure map. Now I can’t get him to spawn again. Does anyone know where his spawn points are if you fail to get him in that location east of Strawberry?

In the snowy mountaintops of the Ambarino Mountains I am constantly under the assumption that I’m being watched. Not by an animal, not even by a human, but something some sort of creature that sits atop the mountains gazing at you just out of sight. Think about it it’s silent up there, devoid of almost all human life but besides the animals I feel like I’m not alone. Ambarino is also a very erie place as well, when fog rolls through I feel like there’s something in it especially when the fog is over the frozen lake. Go to a frozen lake when the fog has come in and tell me that doesn’t look creepy. Many mysterious things have also been seen up there.

The dead couple with the panoramic map that still hasn’t been solved to this day

The giant skeleton

The frozen corpses on top of the mountains with unexplained deaths (who said the cold killed them)

The strange markings on the rocks

And many more phenomena that I may not know of (please comment what I missed)

SOMETHING is up there I just know it… I can feel it

As we know jack looks like javier when he's 19 but when jack is 11 he is as stubborn as 1899 john. Covered by strange man on youtube Abigail was a prostitute so she sleep with a lot of members of the gang. even john says he don't know if jack is he's son. A bit of a clue in RD1 while capturing javier alive a secret dialogue would play it's rare tho "did Abigail miss me" teasing john of sleeping with Abigail. but if you want more information check out strange man on Youtube. I can't link as i'm using a school laptop.