I only started playing RDR when the second game came out so what happens to JM wasn't a shock. I'm curious what the reactions were to those who played the game from the beginning either when it was first released or who managed to avoid spoilers
4,651
pages
ALL POSTS
All posts by Redundantpear
What's wrong with the Strawberry store owner! Valentine Dr is my choice
I'd say Murfree just because of the prolonged assault on women
Biscuit because I thought that was what Arthur was calling his horse. Turned out I was mishearing him saying "let's get"
Williamson is a Scottish last name
Sadie
Double post
(Edited by Redundantpear)
First time round I didn't help as I didn't understand honour.
Second time around I did help him
I think Red Dead Redemption where the gang were at the height of their crimes in a world they fit in would be really good.
Do you mean he points a gun at them?
Sean's surprised and saddened me
Lenny's upset me because it took me by surprise and there was no cutscene. It's as if you had no time to process it
Molly's was frustrating as it could have been avoided
Kieran's was sad but was badass to watch
Arthur's devastated me
H
(Edited by Redundantpear)
I hate it when players do that. I once accidentally trampled someone's horse with my wagon (cinematic mode), and instantly revived it. Second time we both accidentally got in each other's way and they set fire to my wagon, shot me in the head before i could try to revive their horse ?
Nope
I'm curious what other people think of Eliza as we're given very minimal information about her yet I see posts about her having a great impact on Arthur due to her death and involvement in his life i.e. a great love to the same standard as Mary.
How I see it, she was simply a waitress who after a one night stand who happened to have gotten pregnant and Arthur visited from time to time. This is what I gather from what he says. Im unsure where comments of her being his wife, or a great love has come from but if there's dialogue that explains this can you let me know?
@Phoenixskull295 good point
I personally feel that Micah was the rat from the start, there's just plot inconsistencies in my opinion
218 Votes in Poll
I'm quite glad to see other people have the same opinion on Sadie!
I like Baylock as well, torn between him and Nell