All posts by Wintergel
Words that I've seen many, many times, but y'know, Milton was just "doing his job".
While for Ross, he just straight up double-crossed John – thus breaking his promise. 🤡
As a character & antagonist, yes!
But as a person & individual, of course not
Yes, he was technically “defending his leader”, like you say. But there's more to this than “just defending his leader”.
He was doing it, while ALSO:
- manipulating him
- playing pretend, because he genuinely didn't give two figs about how Dutch could end-up
- having bad intentions
- knowing Dutch is not mentally stable so it's easier to play with him
- leading not only John, Arthur & Dutch into a trap, but also the entire gang – including innocent people like Jack, Pearson, Swanson, Mary-Beth, Tilly... (well they're not ALL 100% pure, but you get what I mean)
- profiting of the fact that there's no one to question Dutch's descisions and get him ‘back on track’ or ‘see things clearer’ anymore (aka Hosea)
- and he was doing it so insistently, that it got to a point where Dutch didn't even want to hear what were his ‘sons’ opinions about the situation no more
In summary, Micah just “took to his advantage the fact that Dutch is the leader / the one with authority” to bring the gang to its impending downfall even faster
Even in the epilogue...?
Story I can understand since it would be kinda cool to play as young-John, but for epilogue it just... still has to make sense, y'know 🤔
While putting aside the OBVIOUS fact that everyone will vote Arthur...
While I personally prefer John as a character, I had to vote for Arthur here. Why? Because, with all the respect I have for the devs, I just feel like... epilogue-John was a copy-paste of Arthur...? The movements, the gestures, etc... except the voice. But hell, even when he falls/trips, John's "ouch" sometimes is Arthur's voice, if I'm correct 🤔🤨
They're cute honestly :'>
The only thing that irks me – and that isn't even about their couple – is I saw a video of "what if" you bring Penelope to Gertrude's outhouse (during the mission of giving Penelope a lift to the train station) and she says she will do something to help Gertrude out... but in the end, nope :/
Cleet is annoying on the spot, obviously, but long-term effect it's Edgar Ross for sure
@H. Roosevelt Discovering this at night and it would've moved, I would cry 😭
I think he just grew up the hard way, which he truly wasn't meant for, and it resulted into him never wanting to show signs of weakness/affection in general. But if he would've been treated fairly, I think he would've turned out really nice.
I do also think that the homophobia stuff in the army must've not helped either :/
(though he had a crush on Kieran, and he had fun playing with Cain 🐶 so... yep he does have a soft side)
I remember mentioning something similar under another user's post a while ago, but yeah.... REALLY. Like I know the loneliness felt while riding in the moutains was purposely put there by the devs and all, and let's say they... succeeded very well because holy– I hate going up there
Omggg, it reminds me of a crazy thing that happened to me (but in RDR1) 🤣
I believe after 1914 and only Jack remaining, there's not really much to tell... 😅
A lot more of content before 1899
All of the above, kinda 🫣
I've been free roaming since forever and I don't wanna go further than Clemens Point 🤣 I have like 10k + already HSBSBSHS there should be a secret ending (obviously non-canon, just for fun)
Even if he wouldn't have, he's still disrespectful, racist, misogynistic, etc. etc. so yeah 😐
Valentine, probably. It's a nice spot geographically speaking, plus it's in the middle of the map, so kinda a good place for a city (being surrounded by the rest). And it has everything: stables, butcher, saloon, barber, doctor, gunsmith, general store, etc. Just not a fence but idm that 🤷♂️
Albert Mason my beloved <3
Plus we can get the MFT through the glitch hehe
Well, this is the Red Dead fandom so obviously the poll results will lean towards "Yes", but I'd say he is one of them, not THE ultimate one 🙃
Molly lmao. She's just useless, complains 24/7 and is here "just for Dutch"
@Wagwan piffting23 I think they mean a closer look to og / young John (especially hair & face shape), and not the Arthur-y John we have in the Epilogue