244 Votes in Poll
We don't even know Jack's fate, and Arthur's can be decided by the player, but I'd say John's was at least the most painful way to go (and as said above, the least expected)
For Zoologist you just have to study them and for Skin Deep you just have to skin/pluck them, there's no achievement for getting 100% on them (it also doesn't include Guarma animals)
For Gold Rush, any mission in the Epilogue excluding a couple tricky ones, basically just pick the ones with the least gunplay because they'll probably have the least or easiest objectives
I meant is the location there, like can you even get that far up the map in RDR1 (I haven't played it but I'm pretty sure Strawberry is only in RDR2 and Owanjila is pretty close to there)
Is Owanjila even in the RDR1 map
If you miss a gold medal objective you have to restart the entire story, unless you replay missions
244 Votes in Poll
Mary-Beth at any point in the game is miles above any of the others
I feel like we all need someone like her in our life, though you may not realize it until they're there
Micah is overall a nice person, even if it is a fake persona to hide his manipulation tactics, Catherine is very upfront about her distaste for the gang and admits to kidnapping Jack, that's just the way I interpret the question
Micah is definitely a more evil person, though
They are exactly the same in every conceivable way, it's why neither of them have taken a second to think about how pointless their feud is
^ This guy is in a whole tier above us
A lot of the time I name them after people I know in real life
Sometimes I name them after Phonetic Alphabet letters though even though that’s kind of cliche
^ If you kill shopkeepers under normal circumstances they respawn with bandages
I think this is similar to what the developers originally intended, but most of it had to be cut
Nonetheless, I’m impressed with the amount of effort put into this, well done
I think Seamus will respawn, most shopkeepers do, he definitely will if you haven't yet completed "The Spines of America"
As for William I don't know, I didn't even know it was possible to kill him
Once you skin any legendary animal, you can sell its pelt to the trapper and then you can make the clothes with it that he offers, although most of them also require other perfect pelts
^ I finally ended up finding the other type like an hour or so ago in the same location, I think both of their pelts are just called panther pelt, and they can both be used in crafting for the same things
He is a well written character but I think you’re just looking for either a devils advocate or a psychopath if you actually think someone likes him as a person
The Fine Art of Conversation is really underrated and I think it has probably the best soundtrack in the game (it’s called “The Disaster” if you want to look it up)
Also, somewhat related to the topic, I like the violin that plays at the end of “Americans at Rest”, it lasts for like 3 seconds but it’s awesome
Favorite is American Venom
Least favorite is hard to decide, but probably Eastward Bound, literally nothing interesting happens to someone who's already heard all the dialogue and it's unskippable
90% of the missions in the Epilogue part 1 could also work, but they're usually really short so they're not that bad on their own