So in GTA 5 there is a book in Franklins house called Red Dead by J. Marston. It kinda made me think what if Red Harlow is the protagonist of the book and Red Dead Revolver’s story is the book. Like maybe Red Harlow is based on John and that’s why they have similar scars. If there’s evidence against this please provide it in the comments (btw the stories about Red Harlow in game are known in game so that’s my only evidence against it)
4,663
pages
ALL POSTS
All posts by NateTheGr9
@Jonny Joojans its Mac that got taken not Davey.
I think it’s well known Arthur lost strength with TB (evident by losing to Milton prior to Abigail shooting him) so I think they gave him TB so he didn’t obliterate Micah in the final fight. I kicked Micahs ass with TB so I think Arthur would’ve killed him without TB (and while we’re on the topic of the final fight if the objective was to kill Micah why didnt Arthur just push him off the edge of the cliff. He had multiple opportunities.
Let’s be real. If Arthur never died I could see him and Sadie being a couple. They were both really sweet on each other too. Maybe not romantically but you could tell there was more than friendship between them.
I’m assuming he has to listen to what I say so “don’t break Micah out of Jail. Instead watch his hanging and tell Dutch you were too late.”
✨HoAGy mAcInTOsh✨
Best name by far
Put Hoagy Macintosh in part 4
@Tre Olds took the words right out my mouth. Has everything and since as John I hunt a lot it really helps to easily get paid for lower value pelts
@Nicky Scarfo I would’ve lost so much honor and ammo on those kids if I could
I think I know what R* could do if they make a 3rd RDR. Notice how Arthur was dead and never mentioned throughout RDR1 and was the protagonist of 2. Mac Callander nearly matches this description. I think it could be played as him and end with the massacre but I’m unsure how the epilogue would play out.
(Edited by NateTheGr9)
I wasn’t really into Red Dead until 2. I played Revolver with my cousin growing up but that’s it. I got rdr2 and once I finished it I got 1 and now I have found so many secrets because even with nothing to do I enjoy both games very much. I liked the way I played it because I played in chronological order which is how I like my games to be played
(Edited by NateTheGr9)
Am I the only one that enjoys the bow more than any of my rifles repeaters or shotguns? I originally started using it for stealth but quickly took a liking to it so now I use it in shootouts because I can get my ammo back and it’s about as deadly as my rifles anyways. Less ammo to carry but always replaces itself so I don’t constantly have to buy bullets.
Minus the horse abuse, I agree
The way they’ve gone backwards I think it could be Mac. He was never seen in game and was dead the whole time as Arthur was in RDR1 but should it end with his death, who would we be in the Epilogue since his death was at the beginning of 2