Davey- I didn't really feel any sort of sadness like I did with a few other character since he was only on screen for a split second in the beginning cutscene.
Sean- In my first playthrough, I was sort of shocked and sad at the same time because he was one of my favorite characters.
Kieran- I was sad and kind of hurt by this death because Kieran was one of my top 5 fave characters.
Hosea- I was saddened by this death
Lenny- I was also saddened by this death as well
Molly- At first, I thought she deserved it, but felt a little bit of guilt when I found out she actually wasn't the rat
Eagle- He wasn't one of the characters I ever payed attention to, but his death scene was sad
Susan- I wanted to stab Micah in the face after he killed her
Arthur- I cried during his last ride and his death scene(good honor, help John)
Micah- One word. Satisfying.
Javier- I tried to capture him alive, but accidentally killed him......oops
Bill- I wish he had a redemption arc and wasn't killed
Dutch- I found his story/fall down the wrong path sad and thought he could've went down a better path instead of following the legendary rat at the end of rdr2
Uncle- It was sad to see him go.
John- I played RDR1 before RDR2, so when John got killed, I was shocked, sad, and cried a little. It was very satisfying to kill Ross as Jack though.
Molly cause she never did the work that all of the other woman of the camp did and only sat around the camp while everyone else was hard at work.